What exactly are the definitions
of the terms "Investment & Speculation" and how can
investors differentiate the two? Despite the diligent efforts of some of the
stock markets greatest minds, there are no universally accepted definitions.
Some securities are referred to as speculative despite the fact that logically,
they can be viewed as investments. Additionally, investors frequently buy and
sell securities like treasury bonds (that are considered safe investments by
most) with entirely speculative motives. Adding to the confusion is the fact
that in both the short and long run, investors frequently lose money while
speculators frequently make money.
One
of the most thorough discussions of "speculation" appeared in a 1993
issue of the Journal of Portfolio Management and was written by Martin Fridson
Fridson
divided the definitions of speculation into four categories. The definitions either
implied the use of or involved (1) price changes, (2) quick profits, (3) high
risk, or (4) some combination all three elements.
There
are any number of scenarios that present
interesting questions.
Is
an investor that buys a government bond in search of a short term gain (from
dropping interest rates) investing or speculating?
Most
of the worldwide Government bonds (Treasury Bills, Bonds and Notes) are
considered "risk-free" and certainly are not considered speculative
securities by most. Yet these securities are used frequently to speculate on
the direction of interest rates.
The
majority of individual venture capital investments result in complete losses.
However, venture funds typically yield higher returns than stocks because one
or more of the funds' investments commonly yield many times the initial
investment (thus more than making up for complete losses of other investments).
Is an allocation to a venture capital transaction an investment or speculation?
Speculation
- "the assumption of considerable business risk in obtaining commensurate
gain."
Commensurate
Gain - "a positive expected profit beyond the risk-free alternative. This
is the risk premium."
Considerable
Risk - "the risk is sufficient to affect the decision."
Gamble
- "to bet or wager on an uncertain outcome."
In
their textbook “Investments”, by Zvi Bodie, Alex Kane, and Alan J. Marcus they
argue that the primary difference between speculation and gambling (as defined
above) is "commensurate gain."
They
reason that "a gamble is the assumption of risk for no purpose but
enjoyment of the risk itself, whereas speculation is undertaken in spite of the
risk involved because one perceives a favourable risk-return trade-off.
To
turn a gamble into a speculative prospect requires an adequate risk premium for
compensation to risk-averse investors for the risks that they bear. Hence risk
aversion and speculation are not inconsistent."
Bodie,
Kane and Marcus are not the first to compare the stock market to gambling.
Analogies and metaphors comparing investments with casino games and other games
of chance are commonly used on Wall Street.
Humans
of course, have a long history of engaging in and developing addictions for
gambling. According to Peter Bernstein, the earliest form of gambling may date
back to 3500 BC when a kind of dice game called astragali was played.
In
his book ‘Against the Gods’, Peter Bernstein discussed gambling in the context
of risk. Bernstein traced the history of numbers, probability theory, and the
development of people's perception about risk and gambling. According to
Bernstein, "Human beings have always been infatuated with gambling because
it puts us head-to-head against the fates, with no holds barred. We enter this
daunting battle because we are convinced that we have a powerful ally: Lady
Luck will interpose herself between us and the fates (or the odds) to bring
victory to our side."
At
a time when casino's, lotteries, and sports betting are hugely popular, it's
easy to understand why people might confuse speculation with investment. Mega
resort Casinos have sprouted all over the world and the demand seems to be
never ending.
Israel was divided among seven
tribes by lot. Christ's robe was given to a lottery winner so it would not have
to be cut. The Sistine chapel and its paintings were supported by lotteries.
The Italian lottery has been running continuously since 1530. Lotteries are
played in over 100 countries, and yet people often do not associate a lottery
with gambling.
Perhaps our experiences with lotteries can shed some additional light on
humans' obsession with risk. Millions of people are willing to stand in lines
for hours just to buy a lottery ticket with worse than
"one-in-a-million" odds and yet the same people would not place the
same amount of money on one horse out of ten in a race.
The odds of picking all six numbers in a 6/49 lottery are roughly one in
fourteen million and the odds of winning a thunderball lottery are roughly one
in eighty million, but again, ask the lottery ticket buyer to place there
currency on a single number of a roulette table and they would probably refuse.
Perhaps
it is the fact that the stock market and other investments generally rise over
the long term, that draws speculators to investment markets. As Markowitz
points out, stocks in general are a positive-sum game since they rise in the
long term. But, while an investor purchasing a stock has a positive expected
return, his or her expected return relative to the market is zero (before
costs).
Because
investors have the option of investing in index funds, the returns from a
specific market (or asset class) and any individual security can be separated.
This issue goes to the heart of the passive vs active management decision.
Let's
say an investor measures his performance against the Fortune 500. If he chooses
to overweight or underweight a stock relative to its composition in the index,
is this an investment decision is it speculation or is it gambling?
Similar
questions can be asked of other investors relative to their benchmarks . The
answers of course, depend on your definitions.
Regardless
of how you define the terms, its likely to be a worthwhile activity to estimate
your expected returns on both an absolute basis as well as relative to an
appropriate benchmark. And if you find yourself enjoying the activity of
investing or if you find yourself addicted to the speed and excitement of the
trading game, perhaps you should seriously consider whether you've crossed the
line between investing and speculation and maybe you are really gambling with
your money.
Quotes
"A
prospect that has a zero risk premium is called a fair game. Investors that are
risk-averse reject investment portfolios that are fair games or worse."
Zvi Bodie, Alex Kane, and Alan J. Marcus in Investments
"Speculation
is an effort, probably unsuccessful, to turn a little money into a lot.
Investment is an effort, which should be successful, to prevent a lot of money
from becoming a little."
Fred Schwed Jr. in Where Are The Customer’s
Yachts?
"Games
of chance must be distinguished from games in which skill makes a difference.
The principles that work in roulette, dice, and slot machines are identical,
but they explain only part of what is involved in poker, betting on the horses,
and backgammon. With one group of games the outcome is determined by fate; with
the other group, choice comes into play. The odds--the probability of
winning--are all you need to know for betting in a game of chance, but you need
far more information to predict who will win and who will lose when the outcome
depends on skill as well as luck. There are cardplayers and racetrack bettors
who are genuine professionals, but no one makes a successful profession out of dice
or roulette.
Peter Bernstein in Against the Gods